I had an interview today with a developer/engineering firm that recently wanted to start an in-house architectural service to design buildings for their clients...therefore eliminate the need to have their clients hiring an outside architect and working with someone outside their company. Which means...they have more control over the final outcome.
I initially have no opposition to that...and I in a way respect them for taking matter into their own hand. But when I hear their explanation about their recent changes is because they dont want this outside architect selecting more expensive materials over cheaper alternatives. I begin to questions myself. Coming from an engineer, this comment about the importance of the bottomline compares to what an architect's specified. It worries me. It worries me a lot. What if the material is a green material? What if it have more thermomass? What if this material will last 10 times longer than the cheap one? These ETHICAL and MORAL obligation that I have not as an architectural designer but a human being...that comment bothers me.
If you're willing to sacrifice a little bit of architecture for a little more on the bottomline. I have little respect for you. If you're willing to go cheap on little things like that...what else are you going to be cheap on? Is the only obligation we have as a architect is that it doesn't fall down and kill people? Where's the soul? Where's the architecture?
I felt ashamed that for a long moment, I was contemplating in working for them because of the range of things I can do. But working for a company who is cheap is different than working for a client that is on a budget. A client with a budget forces you to be more creative in your problem solving...because they want creative solution to their scenario. And great architecture is born that way. A cheap firm forces their workers to work in an assembly line...to produce whether than to think. They use generic details, generic construction methods, overly used connections xrefs....generic, generic, generic....just to save a dollar or two. Nothing creative about that. Even if they tell you that it's aesthetically pleasing. (aesthetic is not creativity - I dont say wow when I see somthing pretty...I say wow when I see something creative)
That idea goes back to my discontent with americans being content with their lives. A lot of americans are content with their live, work, + play situation. Anything that will disrupt that contentness even if it's positive, they are not confortable with it. These content individual will carry on their lives for 50 years without making any major changes. They enjoy their "usual" weekly menu. Eat and order the same thing from a familiar chain restaurant which prepare their meal in an assembly line fashion. Go to the same mall, shop the same clothes. It is all repetition.
Repeition is not the same as ritual. Sameness comes from content. Ritual comes from the desire to renew the spirit. The soul. The heart.
I'll end with a
fun antidote